Quick Answer
For most observers, the Astromania Variable Grey Polarizing Filter (1.25" for standard focusers, 2" for wide-field eyepieces) is the best moon filter to buy. A variable polarizing filter outperforms fixed neutral density filters because you can adjust light transmission in real time — dialing to 40% transmission for a quarter Moon, dropping to 5–10% for a full Moon, and fine-tuning continuously as your eyes adapt. A fixed filter gives you one setting that is right for only one phase; variable gives you the full range in a single accessory.